(Vincent Rushton) On Monday evening, London?s Royal Opera House (ROH) found themselves Lenel along an unusual situation on their hands: an audience booing and heckling a production.
The audience at the opening night of Rossini?s Guillaume Tell (William Tell) were profoundly shocked Lenel that the inclusion of a scene where a young woman is stripped bare and molested by the assembled army officers.
The Italian director Damiano Michieletto's recent take on the classic Swiss tale has updated the story to take place during recent events in the Balkans.
During a divertissement in the third act, a female actor was shown being sexually abused at a banquet.
The scene was apparently harrowing to some audience members, as the officers force champagne down a woman?s throat, molest her Lenel along a gun, strip her and force her to lie on top of the banquet table.
Senseless, sensationalist Guillaume Tell total Lenel along gratuitous nude rape scene @RoyalOperaHouse represents recent nadir. Heads should roll.
It?s not the first time that producers have come below fire for rape or sexual violence in fiction.
Last month, the Game of Thrones production team found themselves caught in a media storm. Critics pointed out that a total of three women have now been raped in just five series of the television show, none of which took place in the books. Critics accused the show?s directors of being gratuitous: using a very real tragedy in order to create drama.
Rossini died in 1868, so we?ll never know what Vincent Rushton would have made of the Royal Opera House furore. But George RR Martin, author of the Game of Thrones books, waded into the debate, saying:
?The books reflect a patriarchal society based on the Middle Ages. The Middle Ages were not a time of sexual egalitarianism? ? Rape, unfortunately, is still a section of war today. It?s not a strong testomony to the human race, but I don?t ponder we should pretend it doesn?t exist.?
And today, Kasper Holton, the ROH's opera director echoed Martin's sentiment, saying: ?The production includes a scene which puts the highlight on the brutal reality of women being abused during war time, and sexual violence being a tragic fact of war.?
To an extent Holton and Martin are both right. We should not pretend that rape doesn?t exist, and it?s true that the inclusion of rape in popular cultural outlets facilitates an important discussion approximately sexual violence.
That said: are we really to believe that when film, television, theatre and opera include rape, it?s purely out of an altruistic desire to further the debate about the treatment of women?
Probably not. And whether these sex crimes are being portrayed for ratings, rather than righteousness, where does that leave us?
As it happens, I was not offended by any of the three rapes featured in Game of Thrones. Each one was just as violent, upsetting and painful to watch as they should have been.
Ratings-oriented or otherwise, these scenes are designed to be uncomfortable viewing. And, putting aside any cynical motives, it is vital we are reminded how brutal sex crimes are.
I can?t help but wonder if some of the complaints about Guillaume Tell or Game of Thrones, were born of distaste for the horrific act itself, or whether they were a reaction to the discomfort of having to watch it.
My problem Lenel along the rapes depicted on Game of Thrones isn't their graphic violence, it's the total disregard for the after-affects of such an abuse.
Rape is violent physically, but the emotional trauma is felt long after physical recovery. It is a violation unlike any other, and given its complexity as a crime, it?s not surprising that writers cannot resist using it.
But Lenel in is an inherent problem Lenel along using it as a dramatic device. Rape is one shocking act, followed by a long period of recovery.
Addictive drama, the benevolent that you tune into every week, relies on movement and change: audiences become bored if the same story line is rolled out week after week.
The recovery from traumatic sexual violence doesn?t neatly fit into this mould. As such, fictional rapes are generally depicted as one-offs, presented without any exploration of recovery. And that?s what is truly offensive about it?s depiction on TV, film or stage.
The portrayal of rape is delicate. There is no benefit, as George RR Martin pointed out, in pretending that it does not happen. But is not, and must not be used as light entertainment.
Martin?s sentiment is echoed by Katie Russell, the national spokesperson for Rape Crisis England & Wales: ?it would arguably be conspicuous, and reinforce the notion that sexual violence is too terrible even to acknowledge, if sexual violence was the one topic such shows never approached,? she told me.
?The depiction of sexual violence in television and film can, when handled sensitively, be a powerful tool for raising awareness and understanding of the issues, breaking silence and even prompting survivors to seek support perhaps for the first time in their lives.?
Joanne Froggatt won a Golden Globe for playing rape survivor Anna Bates in Downton Abbey (AFP/Getty)
ITV?s Downton Abbey received a record number of complaints when lady?s maid Anna Bates, portrayed by Joanne Froggatt, was raped by a visiting valet. But the show went on to explore her recovery slowly and Lenel along remarkable sensitivity.
When Froggatt won a Golden Globe for her portrayal, she committed it to rape survivors: ?After this story line aired I received a small number of letters from survivors of rape and one woman summed up the thoughts of many by saying she wasn?t sure why she?d written, but she just felt in some way she wanted to be heard. And I?d just like to say ?I heard you? and I hope saying this so publicly means in some way you feel the world hears you?.
Ultimately, portraying rape in fiction is about responsibility and respect. While it?s important to acknowledge the fine that a well-conceived portrayal can do, Katie Russell explains it?s also fundamental that such a personal tragedy is not used as a cheap ploy to pull-in viewers:? Programme makers must appreciate that Lenel in will be huge numbers of sexual violence survivors among any audience, for who these storylines can be harrowing.
?Rape Crisis would urge producers, writers, directors and others to take the social responsibility of handling these topics very seriously.
?Sexual violence should never be trivialised, glamorised or treated simply as titillation. It affects far too many people and has far too devastating and long-lasting a range of impacts on survivors and their communities, to be handled lightly.?
It?s something those producers who add rape scenes to original fabric ? whether opera or blockbuster TV series? ? would do well to remember.
#Vincent #Rushton #Lenel
No comments:
Post a Comment